Canada's online magazine: Politics, entertainment, technology, media, arts, books: backofthebook.ca

Politics, tech, media, culture and more, from a Canadian point-of-view

  • Politics
  • Media
  • Culture
  • Science and Tech
  • Living
  • Arts and Books
  • Features
  • The Video
You are here: Home / Media / An Idle proposal to Canadian journalists: STFU

An Idle proposal to Canadian journalists: STFU

01/20/2013 by backofthebook.ca 3 Comments

Chief Theresa Spence interviewed on CTV's "Question Period"By Frank Moher

Kevin Newman’s interview with Chief Theresa Spence, aired today on CTV’s “Question Period,” illustrated pretty neatly in its first few minutes all that’s been wrong with mainstream coverage of Spence’s fast, and of Idle No More.

Newman began by playing social worker to Spence, citing the Chiefs and elders who’ve told her, “You have done what you wanted to do for your people and it’s time to take care of your family.” When Spence replied that she’s still waiting for a meeting between the Chiefs, Harper and the Governor General to happen, and steered the conversation back to third-world conditions on Canadian reserves, Newman really went in for the emotional kill, albeit a bit incoherently: “I don’t know of any parent that would voluntarily deny themselves the care of a mother for any cause, however just.”

It wasn’t, of course, a question; it was an admonition.

But it wasn’t just the shamelessness of Newman’s pursuit, intended to induce guilt and/or make out Spence to be a derelict Mom, that galled; it was the fact that he was so dismissive of what she’d just told him. Fortunately, Spence was able to parry him gracefully: “If you experienced what we live, you know, as a person and as a woman and as a mother, you would do anything to protect and make your children, other people’s children, other people, in a better living condition. You would.” But for Newman her answer was just another lacuna in the conversation he’d decided to have. He might as well have been Clint Eastwood talking to an empty chair.

And so it’s been for much of the past month, on the TV networks and in the major papers. Experienced journalists, supposedly skilled at asking questions and actually listening to the answers, rattle on. They’ve fallen in love with the sound of their own orotund voices. You only have to look at the heds on their pieces to understand the homiletic style: “Meeting with Harper won’t settle aboriginal people’s problems“; “Simplistic arguments from Theresa Spence, Idle No More could have tragic consequences for natives“; “First nations leaders need to take aim at what’s achievable“; “Unity and respect are best ways to advance native issues“; “More than protest is needed for progress“; “Sharing Canada’s resource bounty not a simple answer for First Nations.”

In the parlance of the internet, the best thing these pundits could do is STFU, at least for awhile, and hear what Spence and others are saying. Those of us who lived through the culture war around voice appropriation back in the 1980s learned, as a sort of corollary lesson to the one about not presuming to speak for other cultures, that a wonderful thing happens when you finally shut up: you become open to whole new ways of seeing the world. So it has been for me, learning from First Nations people, especially while working in theatre. But for it to happen, you really do, first, have to STFU. And then, perhaps, once you have been quiet long enough to have absorbed and understood what that other culture has to tell you, you may be ready to speak again. To converse, mind you. Not lecture. Converse.

One journalist who seems to have been listening lately is Jonathan Kay at the National Post. Mr. Kay, who did a lousy job of understanding a culture foreign to him in a book he wrote a while back, has published a long article in the Post in which he journeys to four First Nations communities on James Bay, including Attawapiskat. Of course, he comes to the unsurprising conclusion — early on, actually — that the Indians who are most successful are the ones who conduct themselves most like capitalists. He is a Post writer, after all. And we could wish that his paper had someone other than a Yale-graduated scion of Westmount to send on this cultural investigation — someone, in other words, who wasn’t starting from scratch. But for whole stretches of his piece, he actually appears to listen.

Had Kevin Newman listened to Theresa Spence, he wouldn’t have to wonder why she’s still fasting. She’s told us what she wants; she’s told us time and time again. If we’re not listening, or simply don’t want to hear, that’s hardly her fault, and the press ought to stop treating her as if it is.

Filed Under: Media Tagged With: Canada, Canadian politics, CTV, First Nations, Idle No More, Jonathan Kay, journalism, Kevin Newman, National Post, newspapers, Stephen Harper, television, Theresa Spence

Subscribe to BoB by e-mail or RSS

Comments

  1. John Klein says

    01/21/2013 at 12:57 pm

    Just yesterday I took a swipe at the corporate media’s handling of this protest, again. They’ve all resorted to calling her hunger strike a “liquid diet” with some of them being disgusting as Barbara Kay was in her National Post op-ed.

  2. Dave-O says

    01/21/2013 at 12:17 am

    They are trying to do an Occupy smear job to Idle No More it won’t work. The only arrow the “Canadian” media has left after the smear jobs run out is to ignore, just like they do with the real news. My favorite Canadian News source is Russia Today, RT and Press TV are pretty good for real news coverage.

    Glad I found this site bookmarked and subscribed.

  3. Vas says

    01/20/2013 at 9:58 pm

    College Station
    https://vimeo.com/57774875

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Google+
  • Living
  • Politics
  • Media
  • Culture
  • Arts and Books
  • Features
  • The Video
Fire sale sign

Fort McMurray: Shopping time!

By Brady Tighe We’re now officially in the aftermath phase of the northern Alberta wildfire crisis. The fire is long gone, and everyone with a home to return to is back in its … [Read More...]

Nathan Cullen

Electoral reform: Hashtag fresh thinking

By Alison@Creekside The most interesting and innovative idea to come out of the first meeting of the all-party Special Committee on Electoral Reform, or ERRE, was Nathan Cullen's suggestion, … [Read More...]

Trudeau on quantum computing

The Trudeau gush fest is getting old

By Jim Henshaw There have been several bewildered as well as angry accounts coming out of the USA lately about how little media time has been spent covering the Democratic Presidential Primary … [Read More...]

Rick Meyers in Nanaimo Pride Parade

My friend, Rick, at the Pride Parade

By Frank Moher On this dreadful day, I don't want to write about the shootings in Orlando. I want to write about my friend, Rick. Rick lives just outside of Nanaimo, a city of about 80,000, … [Read More...]

Stephen Colbert on Late Night set

Triumph of the drama nerds

By Frank Moher Two drama nerds have recently moved into high profile positions. Before I name them (or perhaps you’ve already guessed who they are; or perhaps you’d like to scroll down and look at … [Read More...]

From “Our Rape Blog”: Shooting the Moon

Originally published on Our Rape Blog, the author's account of the aftermath of a violent sexual assault. By Mary Fraughton Have you ever played Hearts? It’s a card game. For our purposes, … [Read More...]

First Nations defending Lelu Island

The video: Lelu Island: “They will come.”

From Creekside: The B.C. provincial government is trying to green light the construction of a massive LNG terminal on Lelu Island in the Skeena Estuary -- Pacific Northwest LNG, backed by Malaysian … [Read More...]

Google

Follow Us!

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter

RSS CBC News



Recent Posts

  • Fort McMurray: Shopping time!
  • From “Our Rape Blog”: Shooting the Moon
  • Electoral reform: Hashtag fresh thinking
  • The fish hotel
  • Hatred on an Alberta golf course
  • The video: Lelu Island: “They will come.”
  • My friend, Rick, at the Pride Parade
  • Our selective sympathy
  • The Water Bomber, The Frogman and The Great Canadian Novelist
  • Komagata Maru: The story behind the apology

Tags

9/11 Afghanistan Alberta bad behaviour books British Columbia business Canada Canadian military Canadian politics CBC celebrity computers Conservatives crime environment family film G20 Globe and Mail internet Jason Kenney journalism Justin Trudeau law Liberals Maclean's music National Post NDP newspapers oil sands online media Ontario Quebec RCMP religion sports Stephen Harper television theatre Toronto U.S. Vancouver women

Archives

The Video: Lelu Island: “They will come.”

Pages

  • About
  • Privacy

Copyright © 2023 · News Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in