Canada's online magazine: Politics, entertainment, technology, media, arts, books: backofthebook.ca

Politics, tech, media, culture and more, from a Canadian point-of-view

  • Politics
  • Media
  • Culture
  • Science and Tech
  • Living
  • Arts and Books
  • Features
  • The Video
You are here: Home / Media / Not all bad news in the Wente affair

Not all bad news in the Wente affair

10/01/2012 by backofthebook.ca 4 Comments

Newspapers on subway floorBy David@Sixthestate.net

In recent days I’ve done what I can to show readers how horrendously the national media is coping with the news that one of its own, accomplished Globe and Mail columnist Margaret Wente, plagiarizes in her columns. It hasn’t been pretty. First, The Globe unsuccessfully tried to dismiss the accusations as the rantings of an anonymous blogger. Later, reporters from other media offered a wide range of excuses for Wente, ranging from the intriguing thesis that plagiarism is obsolete in the Internet age to the rather ridiculous claim that accusing a reporter of plagiarism is akin to the Maoist purges of the Cultural Revolution. It’s bad enough that I’ve started a link boycott of pro-plagiarism columnists, and I encourage other bloggers to join me in this protest.

However, I also want to highlight the ways in which it’s not all bad news. Some reporters — some rare few — have actually done their jobs over the last few days and, more importantly, have decided to put the reputation of their profession ahead of their desire to protect their own from public criticism. For instance, the CBC has taken the important step of publicly booting Wente from her position on a media panel while the allegations are investigated. The Globe and Mail, notably, did not announce anything of the kind, although the fact that Wente hasn’t published another column since a paranoid semi-apology several days ago may be an indication that she’s on some sort of leave.

Another thing The Globe didn’t do was to give a platform to the blogger at Media Culpa, an Ottawa art professor named Carol Wainio, to explain her views. (Instead, it apparently preferred to engage in cheap shots at her reputation, at least until this was no longer a tenable position.) In contrast, the National Post has done so. It’s highly recommended reading, because she explains her motives for going after Wente, and simply because the Post was willing to give her the space. A Toronto Star interview is also worth reading, for the same reason.

Finally, the Star is also to be commended for having its public editor publish a piece on plagiarism which at least appears to take the problem seriously. This of course stands in marked contrast to The Globe public editor’s attempt to downplay the allegations, and the National Post’s blatant lack of a public editor in the first place (because, according to one of its leading columnists, media accountability is an assault on freedom of the press). Kathy English lays out what she thinks are some of the key differences between how her office works at the Star, and how the public editor office works at The Globe and Mail.

Of course we shouldn’t kid ourselves about what’s going on here. The Globe’s decision to defend one of its high-profile columnists was sadly predictable. So is the willingness of The Globe’s competitors to slam it at any opportunity — and this is certainly the opportunity. The delayed response occurred because their instinct to rush in with swords drawn has been warring with a fear that there might be plagiarists in their own organizations who could be exposed. In contrast, the seemingly pro-plagiarism positions taken by people like Terence Corcoran at the Post and Jesse Brown at Maclean’s are at least principled, even if the principles they hold to are sometimes asinine and contemptible.

In the meantime, I await a full and sincere expression of contrition from Ms. Wente, one that doesn’t wander off into gratuitous attacks on her critics.

Filed Under: Media Tagged With: Canada, Carol Wainio, CBC, Jesse Brown, Margaret Wente, Media Culpa, National Post, newspapers, Terence Corcoran, Toronto Star

Subscribe to BoB by e-mail or RSS

Comments

  1. Brian Landon says

    10/01/2012 at 3:07 am

    Using the integrity of the CBC is a bit of a falsehood. The CBC have reported ‘phoney stories’ for a long time without apology. Take for example their so-called story that Canadian soldiers were handing over Taliban prisoners to torture. When the documents were released to the public it was shown that this was indeed a false story, despite the fact that CBC ‘sources’ said it was true!! And not one apology. Plagarizing a sentence or two is one thing–but fake stories for political convenience are another!!
    Quit using the CBC as some wonderful example of stellar journalism. It makes this commentary reek of bias.

Trackbacks

  1. Green Conduct | Looking for positive outcomes from plagiarism in the Margaret Wente affair says:
    03/02/2014 at 8:57 pm

    […] [small_ad_left]While the entire affair raised serious questions about the ethical behavior of powerful members of “old media”, in general, I tend to agree with the Back of the Book blog, that there has been an upside to the Wente case. […]

  2. Academic honesty is NOT just for students | Dawn Bazely says:
    11/16/2013 at 6:07 am

    […]  [DB27]https://backofthebook.ca/2012/10/01/not-all-bad-news-in-the-wente-affair/8116/ […]

  3. Looking for positive outcomes from plagiarism in the Margaret Wente affair says:
    04/15/2013 at 3:14 am

    […] While the entire affair raised serious questions about the ethical behavior of powerful members of “old media”, in general, I tend to agree with the Back of the Book blog, that there has been an upside to the Wente case. […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Google+
  • Living
  • Politics
  • Media
  • Culture
  • Arts and Books
  • Features
  • The Video
Fire sale sign

Fort McMurray: Shopping time!

By Brady Tighe We’re now officially in the aftermath phase of the northern Alberta wildfire crisis. The fire is long gone, and everyone with a home to return to is back in its … [Read More...]

Nathan Cullen

Electoral reform: Hashtag fresh thinking

By Alison@Creekside The most interesting and innovative idea to come out of the first meeting of the all-party Special Committee on Electoral Reform, or ERRE, was Nathan Cullen's suggestion, … [Read More...]

Trudeau on quantum computing

The Trudeau gush fest is getting old

By Jim Henshaw There have been several bewildered as well as angry accounts coming out of the USA lately about how little media time has been spent covering the Democratic Presidential Primary … [Read More...]

Rick Meyers in Nanaimo Pride Parade

My friend, Rick, at the Pride Parade

By Frank Moher On this dreadful day, I don't want to write about the shootings in Orlando. I want to write about my friend, Rick. Rick lives just outside of Nanaimo, a city of about 80,000, … [Read More...]

Stephen Colbert on Late Night set

Triumph of the drama nerds

By Frank Moher Two drama nerds have recently moved into high profile positions. Before I name them (or perhaps you’ve already guessed who they are; or perhaps you’d like to scroll down and look at … [Read More...]

From “Our Rape Blog”: Shooting the Moon

Originally published on Our Rape Blog, the author's account of the aftermath of a violent sexual assault. By Mary Fraughton Have you ever played Hearts? It’s a card game. For our purposes, … [Read More...]

First Nations defending Lelu Island

The video: Lelu Island: “They will come.”

From Creekside: The B.C. provincial government is trying to green light the construction of a massive LNG terminal on Lelu Island in the Skeena Estuary -- Pacific Northwest LNG, backed by Malaysian … [Read More...]

Google

Follow Us!

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter

RSS CBC News



Recent Posts

  • Fort McMurray: Shopping time!
  • From “Our Rape Blog”: Shooting the Moon
  • Electoral reform: Hashtag fresh thinking
  • The fish hotel
  • Hatred on an Alberta golf course
  • The video: Lelu Island: “They will come.”
  • My friend, Rick, at the Pride Parade
  • Our selective sympathy
  • The Water Bomber, The Frogman and The Great Canadian Novelist
  • Komagata Maru: The story behind the apology

Tags

9/11 Afghanistan Alberta bad behaviour books British Columbia business Canada Canadian military Canadian politics CBC celebrity computers Conservatives crime environment family film G20 Globe and Mail internet Jason Kenney journalism Justin Trudeau law Liberals Maclean's music National Post NDP newspapers oil sands online media Ontario Quebec RCMP religion sports Stephen Harper television theatre Toronto U.S. Vancouver women

Archives

The Video: Lelu Island: “They will come.”

Pages

  • About
  • Privacy

Copyright © 2023 · News Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in