Canada's online magazine: Politics, entertainment, technology, media, arts, books: backofthebook.ca

Politics, tech, media, culture and more, from a Canadian point-of-view

  • Politics
  • Media
  • Culture
  • Science and Tech
  • Living
  • Arts and Books
  • Features
  • The Video
You are here: Home / Media / The Wente plagiarism question grows

The Wente plagiarism question grows

09/23/2012 by backofthebook.ca 4 Comments

Fingers copy and pasting on keyboardBy Frank Moher

This story has been updated below

The furor over what appears to be plagiarism in Margaret Wente’s columns for The Globe and Mail continues to grow, helped along by The Globe itself.

On Wednesday I reported that the blog Media Culpa had identified numerous instances where Wente appeared to have lifted prose from seven different sources without attribution. On Friday, The Globe‘s public editor, Sylvia Stead, published a badly judged response to the resulting online uproar. In it, she begins by referring to Wente’s critic as “an anonymous blogger” and to Wente as “a high-profile columnist” (pecking order established), then notes that the column in question was written “three years and two months ago.” (Yes? And?) She quotes Wente as saying she “doesn’t believe” she ever read any of the source material she’s accused of swiping, and that her column was based on Robert Paarlberg’s book Starved for Science: How Biotechnology is Being Kept Out of Africa. “In hindsight,” Wente tells Stead, “I’m sorry I wasn’t clearer that some paraphrasing came from his work.”

The problem here is that in at least one instance the material wasn’t paraphrased; it had appeared nearly word-for-word in an Ottawa Citizen piece by Dan Gardner the previous year. And Gardner wasn’t quoting in that instance from Paarlberg’s book; he was quoting from a phone interview he’d done with him. Thus, as one tweeter put it, unless Wente had his phone tapped, it’s hard to see how she hadn’t read Gardner’s article before writing her column.

On Thursday, j-source.ca revealed that the “anonymous blogger” is Carol Waino, a visual arts professor at the University of Ottawa. As it turns out, Sylvia Stead knows who she is too, because Waino has been reporting suspicious material in Wente’s columns to The Globe for some time. For her efforts, she received a reply berating her for “[hiding] behind a faceless blog site to very publicly defame Canada’s best known columnist Margaret Wente” with “single-minded zealotry.” The name of her correspondent? Sylvia Stead, while she was still The Globe‘s Associate Editor.

Plainly Stead is the wrong person to be handling this file. As John Miller, former Chair of the School of Journalism at Ryerson, puts it, “The real problem here may be the way the Globe‘s public editor position was set up. It is not supposed to be a job for anyone who has drunk the KoolAid.” He’s calling for Stead to resign, and for Globe publisher Phillip Crawley to “bring in a respected outsider to subject Wente’s writings to a rigorous analysis, and act on the results.” Meantime, Maclean’s Colby Cosh is the first of the big guns to fire. “If neither Wente nor Stead believes that Wente had Gardner’s piece immediately to hand while composing her own column,” he writes today, “then the rest of us are, on statistical grounds, left with no alternative but to declare them the biggest pair of Siamese-twin imbeciles of all time.”

Like Miller, he saves most of his scorn for Stead, as if Wente has become merely a bystander in the matter. But whether she just hasn’t examined the evidence against her carefully enough to come up with a more plausible defence, or is being disingenuous with her colleague, it’s Wente who’s created this mess.  She needs to suspend writing her column, before she has to be told to, and then ask her boss for that investigation. If somehow it clears her, fine. If not, well, at least she’ll have a head start on redemption.

Updates: Globe takes action on allegations against columnist Margaret Wente

Columnist Margaret Wente defends herself

Editor-in-Chief John Stackhouse’s memo to Globe and Mail staff on Margaret Wente allegations

Globe public editor: What we need to do better

Colby Cosh in Maclean’s: The Wente scandal: a satisfactory resolution?

Filed Under: Media Tagged With: Canada, Globe and Mail, journalism, Margaret Wente, newspapers, Ottawa Citizen, Phillip Crawley, Sylvia Stead

Subscribe to BoB by e-mail or RSS

Comments

  1. smartygirl says

    09/24/2012 at 6:17 am

    Good grief. How appalling that the Globe & Mail’s “public editor” is actually a sycophantic fan girl. Yikes. That’s accountability for you.

  2. Craig Burley says

    09/24/2012 at 5:42 am

    It is a shame that Wente, who still needs to be held to account, has sort of disappeared. But she needs to be held to account, and so getting someone in place who can do so has to be the first step. Then Wente can be fairly dealt with.

Trackbacks

  1. Journalists slow to criticize colleague | Perceptivity says:
    08/17/2014 at 1:24 pm

    […] Wentegate, John Miller, The Journalism DoctorThe corporate media ethics machine, Dawg’s BlawgThe Wente plagiarism question grows, Frank Moher, […]

  2. Wentegate » StraightGoods.ca says:
    09/25/2012 at 1:12 pm

    […] only hero here is Carol Wainio, and the bloggers who are keeping this issue alive like those here and here. Keep up the pressure, I say. You are right to question The Globe's credibility, and […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Google+
  • Living
  • Politics
  • Media
  • Culture
  • Arts and Books
  • Features
  • The Video
Fire sale sign

Fort McMurray: Shopping time!

By Brady Tighe We’re now officially in the aftermath phase of the northern Alberta wildfire crisis. The fire is long gone, and everyone with a home to return to is back in its … [Read More...]

Nathan Cullen

Electoral reform: Hashtag fresh thinking

By Alison@Creekside The most interesting and innovative idea to come out of the first meeting of the all-party Special Committee on Electoral Reform, or ERRE, was Nathan Cullen's suggestion, … [Read More...]

Trudeau on quantum computing

The Trudeau gush fest is getting old

By Jim Henshaw There have been several bewildered as well as angry accounts coming out of the USA lately about how little media time has been spent covering the Democratic Presidential Primary … [Read More...]

Rick Meyers in Nanaimo Pride Parade

My friend, Rick, at the Pride Parade

By Frank Moher On this dreadful day, I don't want to write about the shootings in Orlando. I want to write about my friend, Rick. Rick lives just outside of Nanaimo, a city of about 80,000, … [Read More...]

Stephen Colbert on Late Night set

Triumph of the drama nerds

By Frank Moher Two drama nerds have recently moved into high profile positions. Before I name them (or perhaps you’ve already guessed who they are; or perhaps you’d like to scroll down and look at … [Read More...]

From “Our Rape Blog”: Shooting the Moon

Originally published on Our Rape Blog, the author's account of the aftermath of a violent sexual assault. By Mary Fraughton Have you ever played Hearts? It’s a card game. For our purposes, … [Read More...]

First Nations defending Lelu Island

The video: Lelu Island: “They will come.”

From Creekside: The B.C. provincial government is trying to green light the construction of a massive LNG terminal on Lelu Island in the Skeena Estuary -- Pacific Northwest LNG, backed by Malaysian … [Read More...]

Google

Follow Us!

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter

RSS CBC News



Recent Posts

  • Fort McMurray: Shopping time!
  • From “Our Rape Blog”: Shooting the Moon
  • Electoral reform: Hashtag fresh thinking
  • The fish hotel
  • Hatred on an Alberta golf course
  • The video: Lelu Island: “They will come.”
  • My friend, Rick, at the Pride Parade
  • Our selective sympathy
  • The Water Bomber, The Frogman and The Great Canadian Novelist
  • Komagata Maru: The story behind the apology

Tags

9/11 Afghanistan Alberta bad behaviour books British Columbia business Canada Canadian military Canadian politics CBC celebrity computers Conservatives crime environment family film G20 Globe and Mail internet Jason Kenney journalism Justin Trudeau law Liberals Maclean's music National Post NDP newspapers oil sands online media Ontario Quebec RCMP religion sports Stephen Harper television theatre Toronto U.S. Vancouver women

Archives

The Video: Lelu Island: “They will come.”

Pages

  • About
  • Privacy

Copyright © 2023 · News Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in